Top 3 Most Controversial Wrist Watches

Top 3 Most Controversial Wrist Watches

Wristwatches have long been a symbol of style, craftsmanship, and precision. However, some timepieces have managed to transcend their functional purpose, becoming objects of controversy that spark heated debates and challenge societal norms. In this article, we will delve into the world of horological controversy and explore the top three wrist watches that have left an indelible mark on the industry and sparked intense discussions among enthusiasts and critics alike.

Rolex Oyster Perpetual Cosmograph Daytona “Paul Newman”

The Rolex Oyster Perpetual Cosmograph Daytona “Paul Newman” is an iconic timepiece known for its association with the late actor and motorsports enthusiast Paul Newman. While the watch itself is highly sought after by collectors, its controversial status stems from the unconventional dial design. The watch features an exotic dial variant with contrasting subdials and art deco-style numerals, which Paul Newman famously wore. Initially, this dial received a lukewarm response from consumers, leading to low sales figures. However, over time, its scarcity and association with the charismatic actor turned it into a cult favorite.

The controversy surrounding the Paul Newman Daytona lies in the divergent opinions regarding its aesthetic appeal and value. Some purists argue that the watch deviates from Rolex’s traditional design principles and devalues the brand’s heritage, while others view it as a unique and charming piece that represents the spirit of individuality and collectibility. Regardless of personal opinion, there is no denying the significant impact this watch has had on the market, making it a highly polarizing timepiece.

Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Offshore “The Beast”

The Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Offshore “The Beast” is a wristwatch that challenged traditional notions of luxury and elegance. Designed by Emmanuel Gueit in 1993, this audacious timepiece was met with a mix of fascination and disdain upon its release. Its oversized dimensions, bold aesthetics, and sporty appeal defied the established norms of high-end watchmaking, leaving many traditionalists aghast.

“The Beast” features a massive 44mm case, an octagonal bezel secured by eight screws, and a robust rubber strap. Its daring design and large proportions garnered criticism for deviating from the elegance associated with luxury watches. Critics argued that this watch signaled a shift towards a more ostentatious and flashy style, while proponents celebrated its audacity and daring nature.

Over time, “The Beast” became an emblem of horological rebellion and found a dedicated following among those who craved a timepiece that pushed the boundaries of conventional aesthetics. Despite the initial controversy, Audemars Piguet’s bold move ultimately paid off, as the Royal Oak Offshore line remains one of the brand’s most successful and enduring collections.

Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5711

The Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5711 is a watch that exemplifies the saying, “less is more.” Designed by the legendary Gerald Genta, the Nautilus is celebrated for its elegant and timeless design. However, controversy arose when Patek Philippe announced that it would discontinue the Ref. 5711 model, sending shockwaves through the watch community.

The Nautilus Ref. 5711 gained immense popularity over the years and became highly sought after due to its simple, yet sophisticated, design. Its signature octagonal bezel, horizontally embossed dial, and integrated bracelet made it an instant classic. The controversy surrounding its discontinuation lies in the limited availability and subsequent skyrocketing prices in the secondary market.

Critics argue that Patek Philippe’s decision to discontinue the Ref. 5711 artificially created exclusivity and drove up prices, making it unattainable for many enthusiasts. On the other hand, proponents argue that such limited editions add rarity and desirability to the brand’s portfolio, maintaining the notion of Patek Philippe as the ultimate symbol of luxury and prestige. Want to see a truly Rockin Watch? Check out this Patek Philippe Calatrava Pilot Travel Time 18kt White Gold Automatic Mens Watch.



Wristwatches are not merely functional timekeeping devices; they can also be objects of controversy that challenge established norms and spark passionate discussions. The Rolex Oyster Perpetual Cosmograph Daytona “Paul Newman,” Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Offshore “The Beast,” and Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5711 have all carved a place in horological history due to their contentious nature. Whether it be through unconventional design choices, controversial discontinuations, or scarcity-driven market dynamics, these timepieces have pushed boundaries and elicited diverse opinions from watch enthusiasts worldwide. Controversial watches like these remind us that horology is not just about telling time; it is also an art form that incites conversation and fuels our fascination with exceptional craftsmanship. Read about wrist watches most practical uses.

Avatar photo

Todd Omohundro

My initial goal was to have a watch that looks super cool and also take advantages of the amazing smartwatches available on the market but that evolved into this web site to help others learn about watches and clocks of all kinds! The right watch is pretty magical my goal is to help you find it!

More to Explore